The Simpliest Cookie Icing only 5 Ingredients

I am not a royal icing fan. I don’t enjoy making it and honestly, I don’t love the taste of it most of the time. But luckily for me, I am also not a skilled decorator! So I do not have any need to make royal icing because I have the best alternative.

This super simple, 5 ingredient (can be as little as 2 depending on your preferences) cookie icing is actually considered a “glaze”. But I use it as an icing and it works and tastes beautifully!

Even though, my least favorite cookie to make are cut out sugar cookies, they are single handly the most requested cookie I get to make. My people LOVE them. And I love my people so I make them, A LOT! The reason people love them is because of this icing!

This cookie icing will harden, so you are able to stack your cookies, just like royal icing, but you never have to worry about it getting so hard someone chips a tooth!

Ingredients you need:

The only ingredients you need are:

  • Powder Sugar
  • Salt (optional)
  • Vanilla extract (optional)
  • Corn syrup (optional)
  • Water

That’s it!

If you are interested in making your own homemade vanilla extract I have a great blog post on everything you need to know and a printable recipe card too!

A lot of people don’t like corn syrup and get upset that I would inculde it in my recipes. Listen, I’m not going to sit here and defend corn syrup but I’m also not going to villainize it either. It serves a purpose and like anything, as long as you’re not overdoing it, it shouldn’t be a problem. A couple teaspoons spread over 24+ cookies, it a very small amount. And if you don’t want to use it, you won’t notices that much of a difference!

Corn syrup adds a beautiful sheen to the cookies and also helps the icing stick to the cookie. I have made this many times without it and it turned out fine as well!

Helpful Tools for decorating with cookie icing

This icing is perfect for piping onto cookies. I get my piping bags on Amazon where they give you so many they last forever at a great price. But I also have spooned this onto cookies, dipped cookies into this, or used a knife to spread it on. Any and all options work!

If you choose to pipe it on, it’s really help to have a cookie scribe tool. This makes moving the icing around to fill any gaps very easy. If you don’t want to invest in a reusable scribe tool, a toothpick can also work well!

Examples of cookies decorated with this Cookie Icing

I’ve been using this to decorate cookies my entire life. It is a recipe that I don’t even need a card for anymore and I never measure my ingredients. It is that simple.

I’d love to show you some examples of things we’ve made over the years using this cookie icing:

My son and I make these every year for our good friends’ 4th of July party! We always have so much fun. (AGAIN, we are not decorators. YOU DON’T HAVE TO BE GOOD AT SOMETHING TO ENJOY IT! )

A variety of decorated cookies shaped like stars and hearts, featuring red, white, and blue icing with sprinkles, set on a gray marble surface.

My favorite heart shaped cookie cutter has scalloped edges. It is the perfect shape!

I also help coach Little League and I always make the kids treats at the end of the season! Baseballs are my go to.

Cut out sugar cookies decorated to look like baseballs and red hearts

Below are cookies I made for a friend’s fundraiser. He is battling a rare form of Leukemia. Men are much more likely to develop Leukiemia than women and they are also less likely to go to the doctor unless they absolutely have to. Encourage the men in your life to take care of themselves and go to the doctors! Annual, preventative tests can be life saving!

A collection of heart-shaped cookies with orange icing, arranged on a marble countertop.

My son has been using this icing to decorate cookies since he was very little. Below is a picture of some gingerbread cookies we made many moons ago using this icing 🙂 I love this gingerbread family cookie cutter set my mom got for me.

A countertop covered with decorated iced cookies in various shapes, including gingerbread men and round and heart-shaped cookies, alongside colorful sprinkles and flour dust.

I hope what you take from this is that you do not need to be an amazing decorator to make beautiful cookies that taste amazing. You do not need to be great at something to enjoy doing it! Sometimes being “bad” is part of the fun. I hope you make this the next time you need cookie icing and love it as much as we have over the years.

Be careful though! People will demand you make it again, and again, and again!

The Easiest Cookie Icing or glaze

This easy homemade cookie icing is a simple alternative to royal icing! Made with basic ingredients, it's perfect for decorating sugar cookies without complicated techniques.
Course Dessert
Keyword cookie icing, easy cookie icing, royal icing alternative, sugar cookie icing
Prep Time 5 minutes

Ingredients

  • 3 cups powder sugar
  • 1 pinch salt OPTIONAL
  • 2 tsp corn syrup OPTIONAL
  • 1-2 tsp vanilla extract OPTIONAL
  • 4-5 tbsp water* see note

Instructions

  • Put all your ingredients in a bowl but the water and whisk together
  • Add the water in slowly, whisk and only add more if you want to thin the icing out.
  • If you add too much water, add some more powder sugar until you get it to your desired thickness.

Video

Notes

*My mama always used milk in her icing/glaze. It’s a great sub if you do not want to use water. Because of the high sugar content and the low amount of milk used, the sugar acts as a perservative. Some people even like using half &half. Experiment and see what you like most! 
Use clear vanilla if you want a vanilla flavor but a stock white color. Regular vanilla extract will add a slight brown hue. 
You can dye this! I have used both gel and liquid food coloring, they both work fine in my experience. 
You do not have to pipe this on your cookies. You can spoon it on, use a knife or offset spatula, or just simply dip your cookies in. 
Thin is way out with more water/liquid and make a perfect glaze for donuts, cakes, or cookies!

If you’re looking for a cut out sugar cookie recipe, I have a great one for you!

Happy Baking Friends!

Love you more…

Mandy

13 responses to “The Simpliest Cookie Icing only 5 Ingredients”

  1. Mia Avatar
    Mia

    Look yummy, Do you have a recipe for the suger cookies

    1. Mandy Avatar

      Hi Mia!

      Thank you so much for saying that! We really love these around here!

      Here is the cookie recipe:
      https://rocketmandee.com/2026/10/29/cut-out-sugar-cookies/

      I hope you enjoy them as much as we do!
      Mandy

    2. Maddie Avatar
      Maddie

      Hello!! Does icing need to be stored in the fridge or table until the dough chills? Also, how long does it last before icing cookies?

      1. Mandy Avatar

        Hi Maddie! If you want to make the icing ahead of time, that’s perfectly fine as long as you store it in an airtight container or bag. A well sealed piping bag works great too! If it’s exposed to air it will harden. It’s fine on the counter but I always say to be safe, if you’re making this more than a couple day ahead of time, just put it in the fridge.
        -Mandy

  2. Emily Shearer Avatar
    Emily Shearer

    What is the recipe for the sugar cookies?

    1. Mandy Avatar

      Hi Emily!

      The cookie recipe is located here:
      https://rocketmandee.com/2026/10/29/cut-out-sugar-cookies/

      I hope you enjoy them as much as we do!
      Mandy

  3. Laura Ramsay Avatar
    Laura Ramsay

    How much icing does this make, approx? I prefer to make a giant batch, then divide it and add different colors. But I’d be willing to make it by separate batch if the consistency was the same batch t batch!

    1. Mandy Avatar

      This is a great question, Laura! I honestly never measured it because I often don’t follow the recipe exactly. My best guess would be around 1.5 cups. You can absolutely double, triple, etc. this recipe so you icing is all exactly the same! Thank you for asking that.

  4. […] to make. Not because they aren’t delicious but they are a lot of work. You must top them with my cookie icing/glaze recipe though! With that in mind, be careful making these cut out sugar cookies, they are perfect and […]

  5. Kimberly Avatar
    Kimberly

    Does this frosting still set like royal icing or does it stay tacky?

    1. Mandy Avatar

      Hi Kimberly!
      This icing will set up beautifully allowing you to layer details and stack cookies.
      It is different than royal icing as it doesn’t get that hard shell that royal icing does, rather it just firms up. If you’re use to royal icing, it may take some adjusting but it absolutely sets up!
      -Mandy

  6. Rocio B Avatar

    Hola, cuando dices que al secar las puedes apilar sin problema, las dejas secar cuánto tiempo? Gracias y saludos

    1. Mandy Avatar

      Hi!
      This is going to depend on how much liquid you put in your icing and how thickly you applied it to the cookie, as well as other factors such as humidity in your location, so unfortuately I cannot give you a definite answer.

      Most of my cookies set up fine in a few hours, I live in Pennsylvania.

      I hope that helps!
      -Mandy

Leave a Reply

I’m Mandy

I like to make things… mostly friends.

But when I’m not doing that, you can usually find me making a mess in the kitchen, starting another project I probably don’t have time for, or finding a reason to celebrate an otherwise ordinary Tuesday.

I am a firm believer that life is meant to be made, not just lived. That the little things are actually the big things, and that you don’t need a special occasion to make something magical.

Around here, there’s always something cooking, something growing, or some new idea taking off. I’m so glad you’ve found your way into my little corner of the universe.

Stay awhile, won’t you?