The Christmas We Can’t Buy Back

Decorated Christmas tree with lights, ornaments, and a festive tree skirt in a living room

Picture this… It’s 1999, late November, you’re 7 years old and Toy Story 2 just came out in theaters and all you want is to see that movie.

The boys are gone for the weekend so you and your mom decide to get the Christmas decorations out. You’re rummaging through all the boxes of stuff. Holding up the popsicle stick ornaments you’ve made your parents the last 3 years smiling with pride as you show her. She smiles and says how she loves them.

You spend all morning decorating the house. The same old stockings, the creepy Santas you never really liked, and all those Winnie the Pooh Christmas nick nacks your mom never wanted but she got them anyways because you love them so much. Then finally you get to the best part…

The Christmas Village. You’re over the moon excited to set up the village again. All the small houses, little stores, and tiny people and trees. And in the center of town is the large ceramic Christmas tree with all the plastic colorful little lights you always spend hours staring at at nightime. This is your favorite part.

When you’re done, your mom looks at you and says, “Well, I think it’s time…” And you know exactly what she means. It’s time to go get a new piece to add to the Christmas Village!

You run and grab your big coat, and out the door you go. But this year is different. Instead of heading to the usual store, somehow you’ve made it to the movie theater! Your mom surprises you by taking you to see Toy Story 2, and afterward, you find the most perfect toy shop for your Christmas Village. You didn’t have one of those yet.

And just like that, a tradition was born.

When you get home that night, you run inside to find the perfect spot for the new toy shop in the village.

Then you spend the rest of the night staring at the glow of the tiny, colorful lights on the big ceramic Christmas tree you love the most, without knowing your mom is just behind you, watching from the couch, smiling with a cup of coffee.

Fast-forward a couple decades

Nostalgia is for sale.

That ceramic Christmas tree in the center of your Christmas Village? Its modernized version is for sale! Those twinkling incandescent lights? Also for sale! Red and green are back, which is a stark difference from just a few years ago when the latest decorating trend was sad beige Christmas.

But here’s the catch, my friend. You can’t buy what they’re trying to sell you.

Holiday display cabinet with Christmas figurines, string lights, and small evergreen trees

You can’t buy nostalgia.

The world is a dumpster fire, and we’re all so desperate for a time when life felt simple. When Christmas was magical because everyone we loved was there, someone else was making the magic, and we were living in it. The world felt smaller and safer, and our biggest concern was whether we made the nice list that year.

And the marketing team at Wal-Mart knows it.

They’re selling us the Christmases we remember. The colors, the lights, the decorations. All the things that remind us of a time when life felt a little more magical.

But nostalgia isn’t a trend, and familiarity isn’t something you can buy off a shelf.

You can’t replace your stockings every year because they don’t match your newly acquired aesthetic and expect to have the same memories attached to them. And you can’t expect your kids to grow up nostalgic for Christmas if you never let them ruin your vibe with a dozen Bluey decorations you can’t stand mingling with your Ralph Lauren Christmas.

There’s a difference between adding to a collection and replacing everything to chase the latest trend.

Consumerism wants you to believe that what you already have isn’t right. That if it doesn’t fit the new aesthetic, it’s got to go. And that’s great for THEIR bottom line.

But while we’re all busy trying to recreate the Christmases we remember, are we forgetting to create the Christmases our children will remember? Have we forgotten that we can create new nostalgia in the years to come if we add too rather than replace completely?

Your Christmas decorations aren’t a trend. They’re a collection of memories. Every year, you get to pull out the memories of Christmases past and add a few new ones.

That’s where the magic is.

How do I know this? Well friend, I was that 7 year old kid desparately wanting to watch Toy Story 2 in 1999 at the beginning of this post. I spent 10+ years living that tradition of watching a movie in theaters then going to pick out a new piece for our Christmas Village with my mom. I was the one staring at the ceramic Christmas tree with the little plastic lights, a tree I am fortunate enough to display in my house every Christmas now.

And every year as I carefully unwrap it out of its blankets and pull it out of the bin, I hold it up just like I did those popsicle oranments… with pride. I carefully plug it in and stare in awe at the glow of those little plastic lights. And for a moment, even though she’s no longer here, I can feel my mom smiling as she watches me…

You can’t buy that in a store.

Lit ceramic Christmas tree with colorful lights and snowman figurines on a display cabinet

Leave a Reply

I’m Mandy

I like to make things… mostly friends.

But when I’m not doing that, you can usually find me making a mess in the kitchen, starting another project I probably don’t have time for, or finding a reason to celebrate an otherwise ordinary Tuesday.

I am a firm believer that life is meant to be made, not just lived. That the little things are actually the big things, and that you don’t need a special occasion to make something magical.

Around here, there’s always something cooking, something growing, or some new idea taking off. I’m so glad you’ve found your way into my little corner of the universe.

Stay awhile, won’t you?